TY - JOUR
T1 - The 'Yannai Line' (BJ I, 99-100; AJ XIII, 390–91)
T2 - Reality or Fiction?
AU - Fantalkin, Alexander
AU - Tal, Oren
PY - 2003
Y1 - 2003
N2 - Josephus has supplied us with a detailed description of Alexander Jannaeus' defensive alignment, erected in ca 86/85 B.C.E. against Antiochus XII Dionysus on his way to Arabia. The term 'Yannai Line' was coined by the late J. Kaplan, who in a series of preliminary publications attempted to relate archaeological remains discovered in Tel Aviv and Bene Braq to this defensive alignment. Archaeological and historical studies dealing with the Late Hellenistic (Hasmonean) period in Ancient Israel have often mentioned these remains to illustrate historical validity in archaeological reality. This article analyses the finds from Kaplan's excavations (which were never fully published) and examines Kaplan's interpretation of the remains. We conclude that Kaplan's interpretation of the excavated remains as belonging to a Jannaeus' defensive line is misleading, and thus one can not refer to the 'Yannai Line' as identified by Kaplan. We also raise doubts to the authenticity of the historical sources and tend to dismiss Josephus' statement (copied from Nicolaus of Damascus) about the 'Yannai Line' in the form it is described. We therefore suggest that at the present state if research the term 'Yannai Line' should be excluded from future scholarly works.
AB - Josephus has supplied us with a detailed description of Alexander Jannaeus' defensive alignment, erected in ca 86/85 B.C.E. against Antiochus XII Dionysus on his way to Arabia. The term 'Yannai Line' was coined by the late J. Kaplan, who in a series of preliminary publications attempted to relate archaeological remains discovered in Tel Aviv and Bene Braq to this defensive alignment. Archaeological and historical studies dealing with the Late Hellenistic (Hasmonean) period in Ancient Israel have often mentioned these remains to illustrate historical validity in archaeological reality. This article analyses the finds from Kaplan's excavations (which were never fully published) and examines Kaplan's interpretation of the remains. We conclude that Kaplan's interpretation of the excavated remains as belonging to a Jannaeus' defensive line is misleading, and thus one can not refer to the 'Yannai Line' as identified by Kaplan. We also raise doubts to the authenticity of the historical sources and tend to dismiss Josephus' statement (copied from Nicolaus of Damascus) about the 'Yannai Line' in the form it is described. We therefore suggest that at the present state if research the term 'Yannai Line' should be excluded from future scholarly works.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85066196690&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1179/peq.2003.135.2.108
DO - 10.1179/peq.2003.135.2.108
M3 - מאמר
AN - SCOPUS:85066196690
VL - 135
SP - 108
EP - 123
JO - Palestine Exploration Quarterly
JF - Palestine Exploration Quarterly
SN - 0031-0328
IS - 2
ER -