The mechanism of the oxidation of ascorbate and Mn²⁺ by chloroplasts: The role of the radical superoxide

1. 1. The mechanism of the photooxidation of ascorbate and of Mn²⁺ by isolated chloroplasts was reinvestigated. 2. 2. Our results suggest that ascorbate or Mn²⁺ oxidation is the result of the Photosystem I-mediated production of the radical superoxide, and that neither ascorbate nor Mn²⁺ compete with water as electron donors to Photosystem II nor affect the rate of electron transport through the two photosystems: The radical superoxide is formed as a result of the autooxidation of the reduced forms of low potential electron acceptors, such as methylviologen, diquat, napthaquinone, or ferredoxin. 3. 3. In the absence of ascorbate or Mn²⁺ the superoxide formed dismutases either spontaneously or enzymatically producing O₂ and H₂O₂. In the presence of ascorbate or Mn²⁺, however, the superoxide is reduced to H₂O₂ with no formation of O₂. Consequently, in the absence of reducing compounds, in the reaction H₂O to low potential acceptor one O₂ (net) is taken up per four electrons transported where as in the presence of ascorbate, Mn²⁺ or other suitable reductants up to three molecules O₂ can be taken up per four electrons transported. 4. 4. This interpretation is supported by the following observations: (a) in a chloroplast-free model system containing NADPH and ferredoxin-NADP reductase, methylviologen can be reduced to a free radical which is autooxidizable in the presence of O₂; the addition of ascorbate or Mn²⁺ to this system results in a two fold stimulation of O₂ uptake, with no stimulation of NADPH oxidation. The stimulation of O₂ uptake is inhibited by the enzyme superoxide dismutase; (b) the stimulation of light-dependent O₂ uptake in the system H₂O → methylviologen in chloroplasts is likewise inhibited by the enzyme superoxide dismutase. 5. 5. In Class II chloroplasts in the system H₂O → NADP upon the addition of ascorbate or Mn²⁺ an apparent inhibition of O₂ evolution is observed. This is explained by the interaction of these reductants with the superoxide formed by the autooxidation of ferredoxin, a reaction which proceeds simultaneously with the photoreduction of NADP. Such an effect usually does not occur in Class I chloroplasts in which the enzyme superoxide dismutase is presumably more active than in Class II chloroplasts. 6. 6. It is proposed that since in the Photosystem I-mediated reaction from reduced 2,4-dichlorophenolindophenol to such low potential electron acceptor as methylviologen, superoxide is formed and results in the oxidation of the ascorbate present in the system, the ratio ATP 2e in this system (when the rate of electron flow is based on the rate of O₂ uptake) should be revised in the upward direction.