TY - JOUR
T1 - Referential complementarity in traditional Negev Arabic
AU - Cerqueglini, Letizia
AU - Henkin, Roni
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© 2018 Brill Academic Publishers. All rights reserved.
PY - 2018
Y1 - 2018
N2 - Spatial Frames of Reference (FoRs) are mental coordinate systems applied to locate a Figure (F) with respect to a Ground (G). In Levinson's theory (2003), every language selects a dominant FoR among Intrinsic, Relative and Absolute, leaving non-dominant FoRs for restricted sets of cases. Bohnemeyer (2011) enlarged this typology, describing 'referentially promiscuous systems', as characterized by free switch among FoRs and absence of a default strategy used by the whole community. We show here that Traditional Negev Arabic (TNA) represents a new, hitherto unknown type, which we label 'referential complementarity': All its speakers use all three FoRs in everyday discourse, yet not freely switching among them. Different Gs of traditional life, when observed in their traditional locations, prime specific referential strategies: inherently partitioned Gs (horse/coffee-pot) prime the binary Intrinsic FoR; those with no inherent partition (stone/tree) prime ternary Relative or Absolute FoRs, depending on their alignment vis-À-vis the Observer (O). Interestingly, culturally salient objects considered integral to the tent, such as a hosting cushion or a tent pole, absorb the tent's Intrinsic orientation; but outside the tent these behave just like their non-Tent-integral counterparts (stone/tree). In particular, the Absolute FoR is used for (i) culturally unfamiliar Gs (chair/shoe/dinosaur) and (ii) certain Gs in non-salient O-F-G alignments. We conclude that FoR selection in TNA follows culture-specific rules, paying more attention to cultural familiarity or salience than to supposedly universal metrical and formal features.
AB - Spatial Frames of Reference (FoRs) are mental coordinate systems applied to locate a Figure (F) with respect to a Ground (G). In Levinson's theory (2003), every language selects a dominant FoR among Intrinsic, Relative and Absolute, leaving non-dominant FoRs for restricted sets of cases. Bohnemeyer (2011) enlarged this typology, describing 'referentially promiscuous systems', as characterized by free switch among FoRs and absence of a default strategy used by the whole community. We show here that Traditional Negev Arabic (TNA) represents a new, hitherto unknown type, which we label 'referential complementarity': All its speakers use all three FoRs in everyday discourse, yet not freely switching among them. Different Gs of traditional life, when observed in their traditional locations, prime specific referential strategies: inherently partitioned Gs (horse/coffee-pot) prime the binary Intrinsic FoR; those with no inherent partition (stone/tree) prime ternary Relative or Absolute FoRs, depending on their alignment vis-À-vis the Observer (O). Interestingly, culturally salient objects considered integral to the tent, such as a hosting cushion or a tent pole, absorb the tent's Intrinsic orientation; but outside the tent these behave just like their non-Tent-integral counterparts (stone/tree). In particular, the Absolute FoR is used for (i) culturally unfamiliar Gs (chair/shoe/dinosaur) and (ii) certain Gs in non-salient O-F-G alignments. We conclude that FoR selection in TNA follows culture-specific rules, paying more attention to cultural familiarity or salience than to supposedly universal metrical and formal features.
KW - Negev Bedouin dialects (traditional Negev Arabic)
KW - Spatial Frames of Reference
KW - cultural ontologies
KW - linguistic relativism
KW - referential complementarity
KW - referential promiscuity
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85047178071&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1163/18766633-00901002
DO - 10.1163/18766633-00901002
M3 - ???researchoutput.researchoutputtypes.contributiontojournal.article???
AN - SCOPUS:85047178071
SN - 1876-6633
VL - 10
SP - 83
EP - 114
JO - Brill's Journal of Afroasiatic Languages and Linguistics
JF - Brill's Journal of Afroasiatic Languages and Linguistics
IS - 1
ER -