TY - JOUR

T1 - Over-assignment of structure

AU - Dresner, Eli

PY - 2004

Y1 - 2004

N2 - In the first section of this paper I present the measurement-theoretic fallacy of 'over-assignment of structure': the unwarranted assumption that every numeric relation holding among two (or more) numbers represents some empirical, physical relation among the objects to which these numbers are assigned as measures (e.g., of temperature). In the second section I argue that a generalized form of this fallacy arises in various philosophical contexts, in the form of a misguided, over-extended application of one conceptual domain to another. Three examples are given: (i) the reduction of arithmetic into set theory, (ii) the ascription of full-blown intentional states to (at least some) non-overtly intentional creatures, such as Wittgenstein's builders, and (iii) the analysis of some modal notions as involving quantification over possible worlds (or their substitutes). The discussion of the third example gives rise to a novel account of possible-worlds talk.

AB - In the first section of this paper I present the measurement-theoretic fallacy of 'over-assignment of structure': the unwarranted assumption that every numeric relation holding among two (or more) numbers represents some empirical, physical relation among the objects to which these numbers are assigned as measures (e.g., of temperature). In the second section I argue that a generalized form of this fallacy arises in various philosophical contexts, in the form of a misguided, over-extended application of one conceptual domain to another. Three examples are given: (i) the reduction of arithmetic into set theory, (ii) the ascription of full-blown intentional states to (at least some) non-overtly intentional creatures, such as Wittgenstein's builders, and (iii) the analysis of some modal notions as involving quantification over possible worlds (or their substitutes). The discussion of the third example gives rise to a novel account of possible-worlds talk.

KW - Intentional states

KW - Kripke

KW - Measurement

KW - Perry

KW - Possible-worlds semantics

KW - Wittgenstein

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=33750729166&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1023/B:LOGI.0000046068.00813.83

DO - 10.1023/B:LOGI.0000046068.00813.83

M3 - ???researchoutput.researchoutputtypes.contributiontojournal.article???

AN - SCOPUS:33750729166

SN - 0022-3611

VL - 33

SP - 467

EP - 480

JO - Journal of Philosophical Logic

JF - Journal of Philosophical Logic

IS - 5

ER -