TY - JOUR
T1 - Inventing tradition and constructing identity
T2 - The genealogy of cUmar Ibn Hafsün between Christianity and Islam
AU - Wasserstein, David J.
PY - 2002
Y1 - 2002
N2 - cUmar b. Hafsūn, the famous anti-Umayyad rebel in al-Andalus in the ninth century, laid claim at one stage in his career to a long and distinguished ancestry, including several generations of Muslims and four Christian generations. In this article I argue that the ancestry is an invention, invented to serve immediate political needs. There is no reason to suppose it genuine; we have no other example of such a genealogy from the Islamic world and scarcely any from anywhere else; and the genealogy presents other problems. The consequences of this are of some significance: first, understanding the genealogy as an invention enables us to understand the career of Ibn Hafsūn himself in a different light, and the better to assess what he was doing (and when) in the course of his long career. Secondly, we are in a position to look very differently at modern interpretations of his career: understanding the genealogy as a forgery means that we have no longer any reason to see Ibn Hafsūn as a descendant of late Visigothic nobility, and hence casts some doubt on the view of his activity as some sort of local Christian political revanchism.
AB - cUmar b. Hafsūn, the famous anti-Umayyad rebel in al-Andalus in the ninth century, laid claim at one stage in his career to a long and distinguished ancestry, including several generations of Muslims and four Christian generations. In this article I argue that the ancestry is an invention, invented to serve immediate political needs. There is no reason to suppose it genuine; we have no other example of such a genealogy from the Islamic world and scarcely any from anywhere else; and the genealogy presents other problems. The consequences of this are of some significance: first, understanding the genealogy as an invention enables us to understand the career of Ibn Hafsūn himself in a different light, and the better to assess what he was doing (and when) in the course of his long career. Secondly, we are in a position to look very differently at modern interpretations of his career: understanding the genealogy as a forgery means that we have no longer any reason to see Ibn Hafsūn as a descendant of late Visigothic nobility, and hence casts some doubt on the view of his activity as some sort of local Christian political revanchism.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=66949144075&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.3989/alqantara.2002.v23.i2.184
DO - 10.3989/alqantara.2002.v23.i2.184
M3 - מאמר
AN - SCOPUS:66949144075
VL - 23
SP - 269
EP - 297
JO - Al-Qantara
JF - Al-Qantara
SN - 0211-3589
IS - 2
ER -